Collections that don’t line up with production. A bank reconciliation that keeps leaving the same awkward gap. An office manager who suddenly took a job somewhere else and won’t return calls. Practice owners who end up searching for forensic accounting firms usually aren’t browsing. Something has already happened, and the question is who to call and what happens next.
Here’s the short answer. When you suspect embezzlement, a forensic accountant examines your financial records to build an objective, documented picture of what happened and how much was lost. The work moves through four stages: a confidential scoping call, discreet evidence preservation, analysis of the records and a written report. That report can support an employment decision, civil recovery, an insurance claim or a referral to law enforcement. Our forensic accounting services page covers scope and credentials. This article walks you through the experience.

When Do the Numbers Stop Making Sense?
The first call to a forensic accountant rarely starts with the word fraud. It usually starts with “something feels off.”
Typical triggers include:
- Collections that do not match the production reports
- Deposits that lag behind daily totals in ways that do not reconcile
- Supply orders that seem high for the number of chairs
- A staff member with sole, unsupervised access to the billing system
- Payroll runs that include adjustments the owner did not approve
In my experience, one pattern is common: the owner has felt uneasy for weeks or months before making the call. The books of a dental or medical practice shouldn’t produce a persistent uneasy feeling. If they do, that feeling is worth taking seriously.
How Do Forensic Accounting Firms Differ From a Regular Audit?
Many small practices never have a financial statement audit at all. Where one is done, it is designed to give an opinion on whether the financial statements are materially accurate, not to investigate a specific suspicion or trace every transaction a particular person touched. Law enforcement, meanwhile, generally needs documented evidence before it can act, which is often exactly what an owner does not have yet.
Forensic accounting is the process of examining financial records to build a documented, objective picture of what happened, one that can hold up in a legal, employment or insurance proceeding.
That is the whole job. Not blame, and not confrontation, but documentation that stands up.
| Financial Statement Audit | Police Report | Forensic Engagement | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Opinion on whether the statements are materially accurate | Report a suspected crime | Investigate and document specific financial irregularities |
| Starts with | Financial statements | Evidence the owner already has | A suspicion or anomaly |
| Output | Audit opinion | Case file | A documented report usable in several types of proceedings |
| Focus on preserving evidence? | Not its purpose | Depends on the case | Yes, by design |
If you suspect intentional wrongdoing but cannot yet prove it, that gap is what a forensic accountant fills.
How Does a Practice Fraud Investigation Actually Unfold?
The sequence matters more than most owners expect. In a practice dispute, the investigation should generally begin before the suspected individual is confronted, because preserving evidence changes what options the practice owner has afterward. It is also wise to involve an employment attorney early, before any conversation with the staff member.
The engagement generally moves through four stages:
- Initial call and scope. A confidential conversation about what you have noticed, the timeframe and the roles of the people with access to the systems involved.
- Evidence preservation. The forensic team gathers transaction records, bank statements, payroll data, billing exports and system access logs discreetly, through channels that don’t alert anyone.
- Investigation. The team analyzes the records for patterns such as altered entries, voided and reissued transactions, deposit timing gaps, payroll adjustments and redirected insurance reimbursements.
- Report delivery. A documented set of findings that quantifies the loss, explains how it happened and sets out the period involved.
Throughout, patient care continues and staff keep working. Keeping the practice running normally while the facts are gathered is part of the point.
What Embezzlement Patterns Do Forensic Accounting Firms Find in Dental and Medical Practices?
Fraud in a practice looks different from fraud in other industries, and the reason is structural. Healthcare practices run cash collections, insurance billing, clinical supply purchasing and payroll through a small number of trusted hands. The most common risks in dental and medical practices come from inside, typically from office managers, billing staff or others with unsupervised access to collections, payroll or insurance billing.
The patterns forensic accountants see most often in healthcare practices:
- Collection skimming. Patient payments taken in cash or check and never recorded, or voided after posting.
- Insurance reimbursement redirection. Reimbursements routed to an account someone else controls, with the practice’s books adjusted to hide the gap.
- Payroll fraud. Ghost employees, unauthorized bonus runs or inflated hours for a specific staff member.
- Vendor fraud. Fictitious supply vendors set up in the practice’s accounting system, with payments routed elsewhere.
- Petty cash misuse. Small, consistent amounts over long periods. This is often the last pattern noticed, because no single transaction looks alarming.
Picture a dental practice where the office manager has handled billing and deposits alone for years. Collections slowly fall behind production, and each month there is a plausible explanation. A forensic review of the billing exports and bank deposits shows insurance payments posted as received in the practice software but never deposited, and quantifies the gap month by month. The owner and the practice’s attorney can then decide on next steps based on documented facts rather than suspicion.
These patterns are specific and consistent wherever the practice is. We work with dental practices and medical practices across the country, and the same signals tend to show up in the same order. The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners’ Occupational Fraud 2026: A Report to the Nations also finds that anti-fraud controls are associated with lower losses and quicker detection, which is why prevention matters as much as investigation.
When Should You Hire a Forensic Accountant, and What Happens After?
The threshold is lower than most owners assume. A useful rule: if the discrepancy is large enough to produce a persistent uneasy feeling, it is large enough for a confidential call. Waiting rarely improves the evidence. It usually degrades it.
The decision to hire a forensic accountant generally comes at one of these moments:
- You have a specific unexplained gap you cannot reconcile.
- An attorney has advised you to document the financial picture before going further.
- An insurance claim requires the losses to be quantified.
- A staff member with system access has resigned abruptly.
After the report is delivered, you have options. The findings can support an employment decision, civil recovery, an insurance claim or a referral to law enforcement, and you do not have to choose a path before the investigation begins. When you want to evaluate who would do the work, our advisors page lists our team’s credentials, including fraud examination.
Once the immediate issue is resolved, the focus shifts to preventing a repeat. Separation of duties, regular reconciliation and someone outside the office reviewing the numbers every month all make these patterns harder to hide. That’s the role outsourced bookkeeping for practices plays, and it’s why we encourage owners to watch for the common warning signs of fraud. If you’re weighing a change of accountant afterward, our guide on how to tell when your practice is ready for a proactive advisor can help. The IRS guidance on what records to keep is a useful baseline for the documentation every practice should have in place.
Key Takeaways
- Forensic accounting builds a documented, objective picture of what happened, not an accusation.
- A financial statement audit is not designed to investigate a specific suspicion, and law enforcement usually needs documented evidence first.
- Evidence should be preserved before anyone is confronted, ideally with an employment attorney involved.
- Forensic accounting firms follow four stages: scope, preserve, investigate and report.
- Most practice fraud comes from inside, through people with unsupervised access to collections, payroll or billing.
- After the report, you can choose employment action, civil recovery, an insurance claim or a law enforcement referral.
The Bottom Line
If something in your practice’s financials does not add up, you do not have to decide what kind of problem it is before you pick up the phone. That’s what forensic accounting firms are for: finding out discreetly, with the records intact, before anyone inside the practice knows a question is being asked. If you suspect embezzlement in your dental practice, book a confidential conversation with our team.
Reviewed by Gretchen Roberts, CEO of Red Bike Advisors.
This article is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal or accounting advice for your specific situation. Tax rules and limits change; please consult a qualified professional before acting.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a forensic accountant and a regular CPA?
A regular CPA prepares financial records, tax returns and statements within standard accounting frameworks. A forensic accountant examines financial records specifically to identify irregularities, quantify losses and produce findings that can be used in legal, employment or insurance proceedings.
How do I know if I need a forensic accountant or just an audit?
If you suspect intentional wrongdoing, such as theft, manipulated records or billing fraud, a forensic accountant is the right call. A financial statement audit gives an opinion on whether statements are materially accurate; it is not designed to investigate a specific suspicion or document what one person did.
Will hiring a forensic accountant alert the person I suspect?
A properly structured forensic engagement is designed to be discreet. Evidence is gathered and preserved before any confrontation takes place, which protects your options and supports defensible findings. Coordinating with an employment attorney before speaking to the staff member is also wise.
What types of fraud are most common in dental and medical practices?
The most common patterns involve office managers or billing staff manipulating collections, payroll, insurance reimbursements or petty cash, often over an extended period. Forensic accountants experienced with healthcare practices tend to recognize these patterns quickly.
How much does a forensic accounting engagement cost?
Fees depend on the volume of records involved, the period under review and the complexity of the suspected activity. A good firm will discuss scope with you at the outset so you can weigh the cost against what the documented findings may support, such as recovery or an insurance claim.
What happens after the forensic report is delivered?
The report gives you a documented financial picture you can take to an employment attorney, a civil litigator, your insurance carrier or law enforcement. Depending on the engagement, the forensic accountant may also support later proceedings.
